Arjuna's Dilemma
Verse 1.8
भवान्भीष्मश्च कर्णश्च कृपश्च समितिञ्जयः। अश्वत्थामा विकर्णश्च सौमदत्तिस्तथैव च।।1.8।।
bhavānbhīṣhmaśhcha karṇaśhcha kṛipaśhcha samitiñjayaḥ aśhvatthāmā vikarṇaśhcha saumadattis tathaiva cha
Word Meanings
bhavān—yourself; bhīṣhmaḥ—Bheeshma; cha—and; karṇaḥ—Karna; cha—and; kṛipaḥ—Kripa; cha—and; samitim-jayaḥ—victorious in battle; aśhvatthāmā—Ashvatthama; vikarṇaḥ—Vikarna; cha—and; saumadattiḥ—Bhurishrava; tathā—thus; eva—even; cha—also
Translation · English
"Thou thyself, Bhishma, Karna, Kripa, the victorious in war, Asvatthama, Vikarna, and Bhurisrava, the son of Somadatta—all these are ready for battle."
Deep Meaning · English
In this verse, Arjuna provides a tactical inventory of the Kaurava commanders, but beneath the surface of this military assessment lies a profound psychological struggle. By naming these specific figures—men he respects as elders, gurus, and kin—Arjuna is unconsciously validating the gravity of his internal conflict. He is cataloging the attachments that bind him to the material world; these are not merely enemies, but the very people who shaped his character, skill, and sense of identity. This list represents the 'ego-structure' of the seeker, where the mind clings to worldly relationships even when faced with the necessity of spiritual transformation. The mention of 'Samitiñjaya' (the victorious in battle) suggests that even the most formidable external obstacles are, in truth, reflections of our own inner conditioning that we perceive as unconquerable. Arjuna’s anxiety reflects the soul’s hesitation before the final surrender; he is attempting to rationalize his impending withdrawal by emphasizing the insurmountable strength of his past influences. Krishna, witnessing this, remains silent, knowing that before Arjuna can grasp the cosmic truth, he must first articulate the weight of the personal ties that obstruct his path toward liberation.
Arjuna's detailed accounting of his opponents symbolizes the seeker's entanglement with the ego's attachments, which must be fully recognized and eventually transcended to realize the Truth.
Connected Verses
Contrasts Arjuna's ego-driven fear of these warriors with the ultimate reality that nature will compel the battle to take place regardless of his personal inclinations.
Highlights the paradox of wanting to worship one's elders and gurus while they are spiritually deluded, mirroring the inner conflict felt here.
Captures the physical manifestation of the internal emotional breakdown triggered by the sight of these specific relatives and teachers.
Community Insights
(0)Share your understanding of this verse with fellow seekers.
No insights yet. Be the first to share your understanding of this verse.